Illiquidity erodes the trust between the economic players. Such trust is
a precondition to the existence of a thriving, modern economy. We all postpone
the gratification of our desires: we save now and consume later, for instance
or we sell goods or services and get paid a month later. Such postponement
of gratification is at the heart of the economic machine of the new age.
It cannot be achieved, however, if the players do not trust each other to
fulfil their promises (to pay, for example). Alternatively, the state can
instate an efficient court system, aided by active law enforcement agencies.
Keeping promises can be imposed to counter the natural tendency to ignore
them.
The countries in transition lack both: liquidity necessary to keep one's
monetary word and the legal system to force him to do so if he reneges. Small
wonder that solutions are actively being sought by all involved: the business
community, the state, the courts and even by consumers.
Liquidity or Liquidation
by: Sam Vaknin, Ph.D.
Large parts of the world today
suffer from a severe liquidity crisis. The famed globalization of the
capital markets seems to confine itself, ever more, to the richer parts,
the more liquid exchanges, the more affluent geopolitical neighbourhoods.
The fad of "emerging economies" has all but died out. Try
telling the Macedonians about global capital markets: last year, the
whole world invested 8 million USD in their poor country. Breadwinners
earn 300 DM a month on average. Officially, in excess of one third
of the workforce is unemployed. Small wonder that people do not pay
their bills, employers do not pay salaries, the banking system has
a marked tendency to crash every now and then and the average real
default rate is 50%.
In this article, we will describe a few of the global trends. The trends
are global, the reaction is world-wide because the problem is global. Bouncing
checks have become a household reality in places as rich as Israel, for instance.
The mounting crisis in Southeast Asia foreshadows bankruptcies and delinquencies
on a chilling scale.
The simplest method is to revert to a cash economy. Payments are accepted
only in cash. This, naturally, slows the velocity of money-like products
and diminishes their preponderance, obstructing the expansion of economic
activity. An even more malignant variant is the barter economy. Goods and
services are swapped on a no-cash basis. It is money that generates new value
added (by facilitating the introduction of new technology, to mention but
one function). In the absence of money, the economy stagnates, degenerates
and, finally, collapses because of massive mismatches of supply and demand
aggregates and of the types of goods and services on offer and demanded.
Still, this system has the advantages of keeping the economic patient alive
even following a massive liquidity haemorrhage. In the absence of barter
economy, the economy might have ground to a complete halt and deteriorated
to subsistence agriculture. But barter is like chemotherapy: it is good for
a limited period of time and the side effects are, at times, worse than the
disease.
In many countries (Georgia, to mention
one) defaults are prevented by demanding prepayment for projected
consumption. Let us take the consumption of electricity as an
example: many heavy users and numerous households do not pay
their bills at all. To disconnect the electricity is an effective
punitive measure but it costs the electricity company a lot
of money. The solution? Programmable Electronic Meters. The
consumers buys a smart card (very similar to phone-cards). The
card allows the buyer to use a certain amount of prepaid electricity
and is rechargeable. The consumer pays in advance, electricity
is not wasted, the electricity company is happy, the tariffs
go down for all the users. Prepayment does have a contracting
effect on the demand and usage of electricity - but this is
welcome. It just means that people use electricity more efficiently.
A totally different tack is the verification approach. The person making
the payment carries with him a card which confirms that he is creditworthy
and will honour his obligations. Otherwise, the card also serves as an insurance
policy: an entity, not connected to the transaction, guarantees the payment
for a fee. This entity is financially viable and strong enough to be fully
trusted by the recipient of the payment.
This market in credit guarantees is more developed in the USA (where credit
cards have overtaken cash and personal checks as a mode of payment) than
in Western Europe. But even in Europe there are credit card equivalents which
are very widespread: the Eurocheck card, for instance, is really a credit
card, though it usually comes with physical checks and guarantees only a
limited amount. One must differentiate the functions of a debit card (with
direct and immediate billing of a bank account following a transaction) from
those of a credit card. The latter allows for the billing of the account
to take place in a given day during the month following the month in which
the transaction was effected or converts the payment into a series of instalments
(within the credit limits of the cardholder as approved by his bank). But
in both cases, the guarantee is there and is the most predominant feature
of the system. Such cards seem like a perfect solution but they are not:
the commissions charged by the card issuers are outrageous. Between 2 and
10 percent of the payment made go to the pockets of the card issuers. Cards
get stolen, forged, lost, abused by their owners, expire. But with the advent
of new technologies all these problems should be solved. Electronic POS (point
of sale) cash registers, connected through networks of communication, check
the card and verify its data: is it valid, is it presented by the lawful
owner, was it stolen or lost, is the purchase within the limits of the approved
credit and so on. Then, the billing proceeds automatically. Such devices
will virtually eliminate fraud. The credit card companies will guarantee
the payments which will be subject to residual crime.
Another fast developing solution is the smart card. These are cards similar
to phone cards and they can be charged with money in the bank or through
automatic teller machines. These cards (in wide use in Belgium, Austria,
Germany and many other countries) contain an amount of money which is deducted
from the cardholders account. The account is billed for every recharge. The
card is the electronic (and smart) equivalent of cash and it can be read
(=debited) by special teller machines in numerous businesses. When payment
is made, the money stored in the card is reduced and the recipient of the
payment stores the payment on magnetic media for later delivery to his bank
(and crediting of his account).
A more primitive version exists
in many countries in Eastern Europe: depositors receive checks exactly
corresponding
to the amount of money
deposited in
their account. These checks are as safe as the banks that issued them because
they are fully convertible to cash. They are, really, paper "smart cards".
Credit cards and (more cheaply)
smart cards are a way to restore confidence to a shattered,
illiquid economy. Macedonia should consider them both seriously
and encourage them through the appropriate legislation and assistance
of the state. For Macedonia, the choice is to be liquid or,
God forbid, to economically self-liquidate.
About The Author
Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After
the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central
Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org
and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The
Open
Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as
the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.
His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com
your
complete Drop Ship Source Directory ,the same one we use-A fully cross-referenced,
web-based directory of REAL Drop Ship wholesalers for over 500,000 world-class
Brand Name products, updated in REAL TIME via the Internet. For every brand
name we list, you get the REAL wholesale source, their address, phone numbers,
email addresses, web site, the name of the person to talk to, credit terms,
how to order, and when the contact was last updated. All sources are continually
updated and re-verified for accuracy.